Pathophysiology and Treatment of Severe Head Injuries in Children
DEREK A. BRUCE, ERIC R. TRUMBLE, AND JAMES STEERS
| INTRODUCTION:
Head injury remains the most common cause of death in children and
adolescents in most developed countries, although the cause of the trauma varies
by age group and by country. The etiology ranges from falls in younger children
to bicycle accidents, automobile injuries, and homicide and suicide in
teenagers. The category of non-accidental trauma or child abuse is addressed in
Chapter 18. It is clear that with appropriate education and funding the
incidence of traumatic injury to children can be limited.' In many countries the
incidence of traumatic injury seems to be decreasing, for unclear reasons.2
Despite the decrease, the number of children dying in the USA per year from
trauma equals or exceeds the natural death rate. Despite extensive experimental
work there are no new drugs that are currently available that have been shown to
have an effect in improving the outcome from head injury in children. While the
mortality rate remains low, 20-40% for Glasgow Coma Score (GCS) 3-8, the degree
of functional recovery is limited and most if not all patients suffer some
alteration in function, neurologic, cognitive, or behavioral.
Only 7-10% of head injuries are severe as defined by a GCS of 8 or more. Only
20-30% of children with severe head injury will require a neurosurgical
operation and, since the mechanism of injury and the response to trauma is very
different between children and adults, the reasons for surgical intervention are
different from those in adults.
EPIDURAL HEMATOMAS
Epidural hematomas are different in children than adults with regard to the
cause of the hemorrhage, the location of the hematoma, the incidence of skull
fracture, and the clinical presentation. In adults the usual cause of the
hemorrhage is arterial in origin; venous or bony injury are more common causes
of epidural hematoma in children. Because of the difference in etiologies, which
can result in a more benign clinical picture, it is becoming increasingly common
to avoid surgical intervention in neurologically intact children with a small or
moderately sized epidural hematoma in the frontal or parietal regions,
particularly if they have an overlying skull fracture. However, risk factors for
deterioration include a fracture traversing a meningeal artery, vein, or sinus,
or computed tomography (CT) of the head within 6 h of injury showing an increase
in the size of the lesion. All patients with acute epidural hematomas should be
admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU) for observation.
Only one-third of children with an epidural hematoma will be comatose and
therefore rate as having severe head injury, and in these children there may be
an underlying parenchvmal injury, diffuse or focal, that is contributing to the
coma. This is always the case in children who have been unconscious from the
time of injury and in these two groups of children an intracranial pressure
(ICP) monitor should be placed in the operating room after clot removal to allow
appropriate treatment of the diffuse brain injury. In children who were awake
following trauma and then deteriorated to a GCS greater than 8, the expectation
is that after clot removal rapid recovery of consciousness will occur since the
presumed cause of the neurologic state was mass effect and raised ICP from the
hematoma. In this group an ICP monitor may not be required unless rapid recovery
of consciousness does not occur following surgery.
In patients who are considered surgical candidates, appropriate preoperative
planning is required despite the urgency of the situation. It is rare that any
surgical intervention is required before entering the operating room since
alterations in ICP can usually be controlled by mannitol and endotracheal
intubation, hyperventilation, and sedation. Only in a life-threatening situation
will an emergency twist drill hole in the emergency room be required.3 The
danger of such a procedure in a small child is that the intracranial bleeding
then begins again or increases in rate and cannot be stopped until appropriate
intracranial exposure is obtained. Because of small blood volume, if the
operating room is not available immediately the blood loss can lead to shock and
either secondary injury or death. Thus this should never be done without
adequate blood for replacement available in the emergency room. Furthermore,
there is rarely a reason for blind surgery (i.e. exploratory burr-holes) unless
a CT scan is unavailable within 30 mm or less and the child is deteriorating,4
or there is a fracture seen on radiography whose location is compatible with the
clinical picture of epidural hematoma. In children under 8 years the location of
the epidural hematoma is rarely low in the temporal fossa but is more likely to
be higher and more posterior, the tear of the middle meningeal being at a suture
line, often the squamosal. Thus any exploratory burr-hole surgery in the absence
of a CT scan or fracture needs a different positioning of the burr holes than
the classic adult location, and one hole should be over the midportion of the
squamosal suture to avoid missing a hematoma that is higher than the usual
temporal hole and lower than the usual parietal hole.
In patients in whom the decision is made to proceed with surgery, the prime
goal, if there is a low GCS, is to relieve the ICP as quickly as possible.
Despite this it is usually possible to place a cosmetically located incision
with an area for craniotomy that is large enough to expose the likely site of
bleeding. As with all trauma craniotomies, it is necessary to ensure that
adequate venous access and blood are available, preferably cross-matched blood,
before starting the procedure. A formal craniotomy is then performed, often with
a single burr-hole placed over the superior or inferior margin of the hematoma.
This allows immediate decompression of the hematoma and the flap is then made to
include any fracture within the boundaries of the craniotomy if possible. The
bone should not be rongeured away since the closure should always include
reconstruction of the skull to avoid the need for later cranioplasty. Even open
fractures are repaired this way. If preoperative CT reveals only the epidural
hematoma, opening the dura should be avoided to minimize the risk of injury to
the underlying brain. Many authors advocate 'tacking' the dura to the bony
opening to minimize the risk of reaccumulation of the blood but this has never
been shown to be effective or necessary and the decision is usually based on
either the surgeon's usual routine or the degree of laxity of the dura after
hematoma removal. If the dura does not expand then tagging sutures may be
helpful. The important part of the operation is to be sure that all epidural
bleeding has stopped before closure. A drain cannot be relied upon to remove
continued hemorrhage adequately. Fixation of the skull may be done using wire or
slowly absorbing suture. Plating systems are rarely required and add significant
expense to the procedure with no defined value.
SUBDURAL HEMATOMAS
Subdural hematomas are often associated with non-accidental trauma in
children. In children acute subdural hematomas of sufficient size to require
surgery are rare. Smear subdural hematomas in association with diffuse brain
injury or brain swelling are rarely operated on since they play little or no
role in the etiology of the coma. In addition, after decompression of the
hematoma, severe brain swelling often occurs, as well as additional brain edema
and at times direct injury to the cortex as the surgeon tries to close the dura.
The indications for subdural hematoma removal are that the midline shift is
predominantly accounted for by the subdural hematoma, not associated brain
swelling, or that, despite medical measures, the ICP remains high. In children
the subdural hematoma can be in the inter hemispheric fissure or over the
tentorium, and surgery has no role in this setting. In children with an open
fontanelle the interhemispheric subdural hematoma can be drained by tapping the
fontanelle.
Surgical management of acute, traumatic, subdural hematomas consists of
evacuation and hemostasis. Care must be taken in opening the dura as too large a
dural opening may allow edematous underlying brain to fungate out of the
opening, exacerbating the injury to the brain in the area. On the other hand if
the dural opening is too small, the area of hemorrhage may not be able to be
seen. Hemostasis often involves finding a cortical or bridging vein that has
been torn b the trauma, and coagulating it or packing with a hemostatic agent.
Once hemostasis has been achieved, the dura should be closed carefully and the
bone flap replaced. If brain edema is severe, such that the dura cannot be
closed, then a pericranial patch, a temporalis flap, or a dural substitute
should be used to achieve closure and prevent cerebral herniation through the
defect. Once the dura is closed the bone flap can simply be laid on top of the
dura without sutures or placed under another area of the scalp or in the
abdominal wall. If the patient survives, cranioplasty will be required in the
future and if the original bone is available this facilitates the process. If
the patient had a GCS of 8 or less, a motor score of 5 or less or, in patients
too young to be able to follow commands, an impaired level of consciousness
before operation, an ICP monitor is indicated before leaving the operating room
since there is almost always associated cerebral injury with accompanying raised
ICP, which may require intensive medical therapy.
FOCAL CONTUSION
Focal contusions are not often seen on head CT in children with a severe head
injury, although follow-up studies of survivors show such lesions in 50% of
children.5 It is rare that a contusion is considered a surgical lesion in
children as the tissue can often recover and its excision does, of course, make
this impossible. Most contusions contribute to intracranial hypertension and are
treated by medical means. The treatment of raised ICP with multiple contusions
is also by medical management. Children with a GCS lower than 8 with multiple
contusions on the CT scan are at high risk for raised ICP and secondary
deterioration, and despite a good GCS should be observed in the ICU.
Areas that may be safely debrided without clear neurologic sequelae follow
guidelines for craniotomies in general, specifically the frontal and anterior
temporal lobes with less risk in the nondominant hemisphere. Contused brain
usually aggravates the injury because of local mass effect, and clinical
improvement will often be greatest if local pressure can be controlled without
surgery since brain that is left in place can recover whereas resected brain
obviously cannot.
In the rare case where surgery is done for resection of a contusion, a
generouse trauma craniotomy may be required. The clotting status of the patient
should also be assessed before operation as many head-injured patients become
coagulopathic. The dural opening should begin over the area of the brain that is
least vital and be carried to the most vital area to he exposed. Ideally the
dura is left closed over eloquent brain to prevent injury from herniation and
local vascular compression. Care must be taken with brain retraction in the
severely head-injured patient as retraction may exacerbate edema. A safe, direct
route should be taken to the contusion and the resection done by suction with
ongoing hemostasis with the bipolat. In the soft swollen brain, venous bleeding
within the cerebral tissue may be difficult to control but complete hemostasis
must be the goal. Lining the bed with a thin layer of a hemostatic agent such as
Surgi-cel may aid in stopping oozing from the injured brain. Concerns in closure
are the same as those with subdural hematomas.
DEPRESSED SKULL FRACTURES
Open depressed fractures require surgery despite a poor neurologic state. If
the dural laceration is not repaired, the occurrence of raised ICP will lead to
progressive cerebral hernjation and venous infarction of cerebral tissue. The
risk of intracranial infection is increased the longer the fracture is left
open, and this is another reason for closure. Fractures of the skull base that
produce cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leakage from the cribiform plate or the ear
rarely require surgery and almost never in the face of severe diffuse brain
injury. Because CSF leakage occurs early, the ICP may remain low for the first
few' days until the leakage stops and then it will rise. In this setting the ICP
monitor should not be removed until 48 h after the CSF leak has stopped.
Severe basal frontal fractures of the type that occur with slow crushing
injuries of the head6 can be very difficult to handle. In this setting there is
the risk of injury to the anterior cerebral arteries with risk of secondary
hemorrhage plus traumatic encephalocele of the floor of the frontal fossa. If
the traumatic encephalocele is not repaired then secondary damage can occur to
the basal frontal lobes and possibly the hypothalamus as a result of anterior
and inferior herniation. On the other hand repair of these lesions in the face
of acutely raised ICP is difficult and runs the risk of brain injury secondary
to surgerv and retraction injury. The decision on the correct timing for surgery
is difficult. If there is frank cerebral herniation through the frontal skull
base on the initial CT or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan, if MR
angiographv suggests injury to the anterior cerebral artery, or if a large
frontal hematoma is present, the best time to operate is as early as possible
before severe brain swelling occurs. Whether other facial fractures should be
fixed at this time will depend on the exposure, the clinical state of the child,
and the experience of the operating team with this type of injury. If there are
other surface compound fractures that require surgerv then all the lesions
should be taken care of at the same time, if possible, with pericranial grafts
to the frontal skull base and bony reconstitution of the base to prevent renewed
herniation.
Other penetrating wounds should in general be debrided but this will depend
on the clinical state of the child, the clotting studies, and the expectation of
survival. In the urban population over the age of 10 years, gunshot wounds are
now the most common cause of penetrating head injurv in children. Gunshot wounds
to the brain are operated on only if there is a chance of survival and
recovery.7 Most of the injury associated with gunshot wounds is caused by
dispersion of kinetic energy along the brain. The speed and resulting heat of
the bullet usually sterilizes the bullet but bone fragments remain a source of
possible infection. With a GCS of 3, the mortality rate approaches 100% and an
argument can be made that no surgery will alter the outcome. A higher GCS is an
indication for debridement and closure of the dura. Skin should likewise be
debrided and closed. Again, preoperative CT is valuable in assessing the course
of the bullet and associated hematomas. All patients who have sustained a
gunshot wound of the brain and are considered to be viable require an ICP
monitor.
Dog bites and other penetrating injuries are usually associated with a
preserved level of consciousness and in these cases debridement is usually
performed early. For patients with penetrating head injuries caused by a sharp
instrument in whom the GCS is low and surgery necessary, care must be taken not
to disturb the instrument until proximal and distal control had been obtained in
the operating room. If possible, preoperative CT should be done to localize the
trajectory and depth of the injury. The site of injury is often around the face,
specifically through the eye. In those cases, intradural and extradural
exploration will maximize the ease of removal of the instrument. Should bleeding
be encountered, one must be ready for rapid exploration. Every effort should be
made to remove the entire foreign body and close the dura. The bone should then
be reconstructed. Intravenous antibiotics are indicated for a minimum of 3 days,
more based on extent of contamination.
Raised ICP without focal mass is a multifactorial pathophysiology which
includes, brain swelling, diffuse axonal injury, ischemia, contusion, or edema.
Appropriate treatment of this entity is non-surgical (see below). In rare cases
where the raised ICP can be controlled, but only transiently, by altering
medical management, decompressive craniectomy has been proposed. This is rarely
necessary in children and is appropriate in only a small number of cases. Care
should be taken to preserve the bone, usually in a bone freezer, for replacement
after resolution of the acute traumatic episode.
Different pathology at different times
The result of traumatic brain injury is not a single pathologic event but a
series of pathophysiologic changes that vary both in severity and over time such
that no two head injuries are quite the same. The surgical mass lesions usually
occur early after trauma and in general the sooner they are removed the better;
certainly, the better the GCS at the time of removal the greater possibility of
a good outcome. The other pathologic processes that are grossly apparent on scan
and at autopsy are DAT, contusions, areas of focal ischemia, diffuse brain
swelling, brain edema, increased CSF, and hydrocephalus. Vascular factors are
also important; although the true incidence of vascular spasm is unclear, this
is certainly a cause of secondary deterioration that has not received adequate
attention. Even DAT is and the very early axonal lesions may repair themselves
and are then followed by secondary axonal damage due to progressive molecular
events occurring within the axonal cytoplasm. Many other molecular alterations
have been described and the expression of these agents varies with time after
the injury. 18-25 Two of the more important molecular mechanisms, at least in
animal models, have been free radical production and the release of neurotoxic
neurotransmitters. Free iron and excess oxygen are triggers for free radical
formation. The presence of tissue acidosis aggravates the tissue increases in
the neurotoxic transmitters by further inhibiting uptake. Nitric oxide may also
interfere with tissue reuptake of glutamate and aspartate. Here again, a cascade
of events occurs over time. These areas of molecular change are currently the
focus for pharmacologic efforts to modify the injury. As will be reiterated
several times, is becoming clear that the pathology associated with death of the
child may be different from that associated with survival, especially good
quality of survival, and thus the benefits of chemical modulation may be seen in
the quality of survivors' lives rather than in a decrease in mortality rate.
Brain swelling and brain edema may have different time courses after injury,
and some of this may be dependent on the occurrence of early ischemia and
hvpoxia. Brain swelling and loss of CSF spaces remains a common finding on the
CT scan after head injury. Initial studies suggested this was due to vascular
engorgement and also that increased cerebral blood flow (CBF) could be
contributory. Experimental studies do show increased blood volume as a major
component of the early swelling and clinical findings also support this thesis.
Indeed, careful review of the CT scan suggests at least two patterns and maybe
three, depending on the classification of the scan. In patients who present with
a low GCS, 3 or 4, the brain density on the CT scan may be low, suggesting
ongoing ischemia. In these children the ICP is usually over 30 torr despite
resuscitation, the CBF is low, and morbidity is high. There is another group of
children with normal or hyperdense brains in whom diffuse swelling is also
present but in whom ICP is normal or easily controlled, and this group overlaps
with those with increased CBF. Recent studies of CBF in adults and children show
that CBF is usually at its lowest level in the first few hours despite adequate
resuscitation and normalization of systemic parameters. Over the next several
days CBF increases in those who survive and death is most likely in those with
the lowest early CBF coupled with minimal increase in the following days. While
CBF is increasing CMRo2, is usually decreasing, resulting in a
further increase of jugular bulb partial pressure of oxygen (PO2). In
most patients, even those with low CBF, the AVDo2 is low and cerebral
metabolism does not appear to be in excess of cerebral flow. Those with the
lowest metabolism are most likely to die, yet if recovery occurs there is no
apparent correlation with early metabolism and degree of recovery. Increased
metabolism can occur and there are probably regional variations but ongoing
evidence for ischemia is poorly substantiated. In children with increased CBF a
late occurrence of further excessive CBF with increased ICP may be a sign of
loss of auto regulation and is also associated with high morbidity. While the
early swelling is most likely due to increased blood volume not necessarily
accompanied by increased blood flow, a recent experimental study has suggested
that the early swelling may be due to increased cerebral water, although the
exact location of the water has not been clarified.48 In conclusion, the finding
of diffuse brain swelling is more common in children than in adults. The exact
cause is not proven but it is likely that there are several physiologic events
that produce a similar pattern: hyperemia, which may be rarer than first
suggested; vascular congestion yet without hyperemia; and increased water
content, brain edema within cells. The clinical course and outcome will depend
on the cause of the swelling which, in turn, is modified by the immediate
posinjurv occurrence of ischemia and hypotension.
Correlation of physiologic findings with recovery becomes important since
current studies suggest that early low CBF carries a very poor prognosis, and
that diffuse brain swelling when resulting from ischemia, portends a poor
outcome whereas when not accompanied by low CBF is associated with good
recovery. Is the outcome already programmed in the first few minutes after
injury or can it be modified by therapy and, if so, which pathologies can be
modified by current therapy?
Cerebral contusions are rarely seen acutely yet follow-up studies of severely
head-injured children show that approximately 50% will have evidence of frontal
basal and anterior temporal cortical injury. There is a high incidence of
ischemic injury in children who die after head trauma yet focal ischemic lesions
are rare in follow-up MRI studies. DAT is a common autopsy finding in children
who die after head trauma yet in follow-up MM studies is seen in only a small
proportion, 15%. These findings may suggest that children who survive and
recover from the injury may not simply have incurred less extensive injury than
those who die but also may have different pathology.
Even in the acute ICU care phase of the head-injured child, there is not a
single pathology to be considered but a continuing variation of potential
pathophysiologic changes, some of which can be identified by clinical monitoring
and are amenable to manipulation now, and some that we cannot identify or treat
at present. An awareness of the changing pathology is the underpinning of
current therapy, and modern monitoring techniques (e.g. ICP, AJD02,
CBF, transcranial Doppler ultrasonographv and evoked responses) are designed to
help identify these changes.
Non-surgical management
Much of the pathophysiology of head trauma is non-surgical and even in
children with a GCS of less than 8 who require surgery there is almost always
underlying brain injury that is not treated by the operative procedure. It is
rare that traumatic unconsciousness in children is caused or perpetuated by
increased ICP, although raised ICP will occur in 75% of severely head-injured
children. The few situations in which a direct relationship can be established
between local or global pressure changes and altered state of consciousness are
related to minor or moderate trauma with the delayed development of epidural or
subdural hematomas or acute brain swelling. In both the former cases, if the
clot is removed before the onset of coma, rapid and almost complete recovery is
to be expected because there is minimal underlying primary brain injury. If clot
removal is delayed then secondary brain injurv can occur related to cerebral
herniation and increased ICP with decreased CBF and resultant ischemia. The
current management of head trauma is based on the concept of primary and
secondary injury. The primary injury is that which occurs in the few'
milliseconds in which the trauma occurs and remains untreatable by any direct
means. Secondary injury includes all the events that may be triggered by the
primary injury but progress to cause additional damage to the brain.
The primary injury consists of damage to all layers of the cranium: scalp,
skull, and intracranial contents. Intracranial contents that are injured include
the neurons, the cell body, dendrites and axons, glial cells, myelin sheaths,
and blood vessels. Recent studies have identified a cell structure connecting
the cell membrane to the nucleus, and traction on this skeleton can affect gene
expression. This mechanism may account for some of the molecular changes that
occur within the cells following trauma.
Secondary injury is composed of the pathologic processes that begin at the
time of the immediate injury and are progressive. They include molecular events
(e.g. neurotoxic injury, lipid peroxidation, and diffuse axonal injury) as well
as new pathophysiologic injuries that occur as a result of systemic hypoxia,
hypercarbia, hypotension, and intracranial hypertension. In addition, secondary
injury can be precipitated by vascular spasm, coagulopathy, electrolyte
disturbances, and seizures. Some injuries result in a clear combination of
primary and secondary pathology (e.g. epidural hematoma). The tear of the middle
meningeal artery is primary but, as bleeding continues or restarts, the local
pressure in the brain and the ICP rise to produce secondary damage from cerebral
herniation of the temporal lobe with local brainstem ischemia and/or by
diffusely raised ICP affecting cerebral perfusion and resulting in general
cerebral ischemia from low CBF.
There is ongoing debate as to how often there is continuing cerebral ischemia
after adequate resuscitation since the presence or absence of such pathology
should have a major influence on what the most appropriate early therapy should
be. While early oligemia occurs, as measured by CBF studies, there is no
evidence suggesting that this represents ongoing ischemia since the AJD07 is
usually low and at least global CBF is adequate for metabolism. There is no
evidence that this low flow can be increased to raise metabolism, and the
oligemia seems to be a reflection of severe injury with the prime change being
decreased metabolism. The therapy of head injury is still focused primarily on
the prevention of secondary injuries, beginning at the injury site and
continuing through transport, the emergency room, radiology, and the ICU.
Despite much experimental evidence, no reliable drugs are yet available to
interfere with the molecular, secondary injury. To date neurotoxic blockers,
calcium channel blockers, and free radical scavengers have not been demonstrated
to have any benefit.
The systemic pathologic processes that are modified by therapy are hypoxemia,
hypercarbia, and hvpotension. The intracranial pathology consists of focal mass
lesions, usually hematomas; brain swelling; brain edema; brain contusion;
diffuse axonal injury; and raised ICP either locally producing focal brain
herniation or generally producing a lowering of CBF and generalized brain
ischemia. Brain edema can occur in the cells themselves, neurons and glial cells
(intracellular or cytotoxic), usually as a result of inadequate substrate, most
commonly oxygen, or it can occur in the extracellular space, usually of the
white matter, as a result of damage to the blood-brain barrier in the capillary
vessels (vasogenic). Vasogenic edema is uncommon in the first 24-48 h after
trauma except surrounding an intracerebral hematoma. The early low-density
changes seen in the brain soon after trauma (focal low density on CT scan) are
probably the result of ischemia and hypoxia that occurred at the accident scene
and represent cvtotoxic edema, although exactly which cell population is
primarily involved is not clear. This 'low-density' brain can occur very early
after the injury and seems to occur especially in the infants who suffer
nonaccidental injury. In older children it is more common to see the changes of
loss of gray matter to white matter differentiation occurring 3-5 days after
injury at a time when the ICP is a problem to control. Once again, the question
is whether this is the result of an ischemic or hypoxic injury at the time of
the trauma or progressive ischemia despite normal perfusion pressure for several
days. The former seems more likely since there are no studies of CBF showing
ongoing ischemia in the presence of normal ICP.
CBF studies in children have shown variable results, although most have
measured some degree of hyperemia after 24 h. Study of CBF early, 12 h
following trauma, suggest two populations of injured children: one in which the
early CBF is low (<40% of normal) and one in which the CBF is near normal
(<75% of normal). These two populations both show an increase in CBF at 48 h
but in the former group the flow is greater than 40 ml per 100 g per mm and in
the latter less than 75 ml per 100 g per mm. Mortality and serious morbidity
rates are much higher in the former group.6° Pressure auto regulation, chemical
auto regulation, and carbon dioxide responses of the cerebral vessels seem to be
intact except in the most severely damaged brains.
Cerebral metabolism after severe head injury may be decreased or increased
and the changes may be regional, similar to those shown in animal models.
Measurement of regional cerebral metabolism cannot be easily obtained in the
acute stages of head injuries in children. Since the cerebral metabolism rate
(CMR) can be calculated as the AV difference x CBF/100, the jugular venous
oxygen content or saturation can give some idea of the balance between flow and
metabolism, and may therefore be helpful in the selection of therapy to lower
ICP or increase systemic arterial pressure (SAP).
Normal intracranial homeostasis permits reciprocal changes in volume to occur
between the various intracranial components - blood volume, CSF, and brain -
such that an increase in the volume of one component can be offset by a decrease
in the volume of the others, and thus the ICP kept relatively constant. Also,
the length of time for which the ICP can be raised is limited by this same
homeostatic mechanism. Unfortunately, after severe trauma all the components of
the intracranial space may be increased simultaneously or sequentially; thus the
high incidence of intracranial hypertension is not surprising. The blood volume
can be increased by:
-
severe hypoxia Pa02> 50 mmHg;
-
hypercarbia;
-
cerebral hyperemia;
-
raised ICP and vascular congestion;
-
patient position and venous distension;
-
systemic hypotension or decreased cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP);
-
defective autoregulation and decreased vascular tone.
The CSF volume can be increased by:
-
hyperemia and increased CSF production;
-
ventricular obstruction by swelling or mass effect;
-
increased outflow resistance due to
-
brain swelling and compressed arachnoid pathways
-
subarachnoid hemorrhage
-
cerebral herniation.
Brain volume can increase as a result of:
-
intraparenchymal hematoma;
-
cerebral contusion;
-
brain edema (cytotoxic, vasogenic).
Finally, there can be the addition of new volume to the intracranial space as
a result of subdural or epidural hemorrhage. As a result, the normal homeostatic
mechanisms are blocked and therefore minor changes in intracranial volume can
result in large increases in ICP and it must be assumed that these children are
functioning on the steep portion of the volume-pressure curve. In addition,
because of the small intracranial volume in the child, the actual volume
required to increase the ICP is small: a pressure-volume index (PVT) of 5 ml in
children aged under 1 year. This accounts for the high frequency of raised ICP
in children after severe head injury.
Direct vascular effects, predominantly vasospasm, are probably common in
severely injured children since subarachnoid hemorrhage on the first CT scan has
been reported in up to 75% of such children63 and adult studies have shown a
strong correlation between subarachnoid hemorrhage and symptomatic vasospasm
after trauma.'3 Care of the head-injured child and selection of monitoring and
therapy are based on an understanding of the ongoing pathophysiology.
EMERGENCY RESUCCITATION
The primary approach, which begins at the accident scene, is based on the
standard ABCs of resuscitation.
Establish an open airway by cleaning the mouth, being careful not to induce
gagging or vomiting. Position the patient flat to maximize perfusion of the
brain in case systemic hypotension occurs or is present. Keep the head in the
midline to avoid jugular compression and prevent further spinal injury in the
event of existing spinal instability.
Ensure that adequate ventilation is occurring and if not instigate artificial
ventilation by bag and mask or by endotracheal intubation. In children without
facial injuries, bag and mask ventilation can be accomplished without extension
of the neck, 'the sniffing position'. Pressure on the cricoid cartilage will
avoid distending the stomach with air. The open airway and adequate ventilation
will correct hypercarbia and the addition of supplemental oxygen will avoid
hypoxia. Children who arrive at hospital hypoxic have a worse outcome than those
who are normoxic or hyperoxic
Finally, paving attention to circulation to reverse systemic hypotension, if
present, is the third of the ABCs. Insertion of an intravenous or intraosseous
line may be required at the site. Isotonic or hypertonic fluid should alwavs be
used for resuscitation, and never hvpotonic fluid such as dextrose and water or
one-quarter strength saline. In children, glucose-containing solutions are not
necessary since the sympathetic response to the injury usually induces
hyperglycemia. In infants, glucose free solutions are used initially and blood
glucose levels are checked as soon as possible. If the level is low, glucose is
given.
Associated spinal injury is rare in childhood 1.5 per 100000 compared with
350 per 100000 for head injuries) and, while careful movement of the patient as
a log is important, spine boards are not made for small children and infants and
are better avoided in these under 2 years of age. At this age the large
calvarium is forced into flexion by the spine board and this can compromise both
the airway and the spine.
Following resuscitation, the child should be transferred to a center capable
of the care of children.
EMERGENCY ROOM CARE
A complete physical examination of the unclothed child is carried out. For
young children appropriate overhead warming lights should be available to
prevent a major drop in temperature, which can occur very easily in the child
because of the relatively large surface area to weight ratio. Any tendency to
lose heat will be aggravated by muscle paralysis and sedation, which prevent
shivering and thus increase the rate of onset of hypothermia, and are present in
the intubated child. Evidence of multiple trauma to chest, abdomen, or skeleton
is documented. An immediate set of vital signs to document pulse rate and blood
pressure is recorded. A large venous access line, Foley catheter if there is no
evidence of perineal injury, and an arterial line are placed and blood is sent
for stat studies of CBC, type and cross-match, Prothrombin time (PT) and partial
thromboplastin time (PTT), electrolytes, and amylase levels. If an endotracheal
tube is not in place, it is now placed in children with a GCS of less than 8 or
those in shock. This is best done with bag and mask hyperventilation,
nondepolarizing muscle paralysis, and, unless severe hypotension is present,
pentothal or a similar drug to prevent the increase in ICP that occurs with
intubation and to avoid vocal cord spasm. Once the endotracheal tube is in
place, the aim is for a Fao2 of over 100 mmHg and a Paco2
of around 30 mmHg. An immediate chest radiograph is taken to document adequate
position of the endotracheal tube and to evaluate any intrathoracic pathology.
Once the child is stable appropriate radiologic studies are obtained. This
will involve noncontrast CT of the head and usually upper spine to C3, if a
spiral scanner is available. Plain cervical spine radiographs are usually
obtained, although it must be remembered that up to 60% of spine injuries in
children may be SCIWORA (spinal cord injury without bony abnormalities). Usually
CT of the abdomen is done if there is any suspicion of abdominal trauma. Other
radiographs will depend on the history and the examination.
The period where the child leaves the emergency room to go to the radiology
department is often one of least monitoring and is a time of high risk for
secondary injury. Thus the use of portable monitoring that records (pulse
oximetry, blood pressure, pulse rate, and ICP) is valuable. In children with a
GCS of 8 or less and/or with hypotension it is easy to insert an ICP monitor in
the emergency room at the time of A-line and venous line insertion. This gives
an accurate measure of the effects of fluid resuscitation, position, and
transport on the ICP and allows for logical therapy to maintain it below 15
mmHg. Most of the early mortality from head injury is the result of intracranial
hypertension and it is easier to prevent the onset of intracranial hypertension
than to try to treat it once it has occurred. Even in the event of severe
intracranial hypertension, if the ICP can be controlled, recovery can be good.
INTENSIVE CARE UNIT
Correction of any residual systemic abnormality is the first step: acidosis,
hypotension, hypoxia, and hypercarbia. Abnormal clotting studies are common in
children and should be corrected as soon as possible.67 Hvponatremia, possibly
related to overproduction of atrial naturetic factor or salt wasting, is common
in severely injured children, although it may be delayed for 24 h or more, and
fluid balance and electrolytes must be followed carefully to identify early
changes in serum sodium levels that can then be corrected, thus avoiding severe
hyponatremia and brain swelling. The drop in serum sodium concentration can be
dramatic and abrupt, and may precipitate severely raised ICP
Additional monitoring will often include the insertion of an internal jugular
bulb catheter. This can usually be performed quite satisfactorily with the child
flat in bed and avoiding the head-lowered position, which can increase ICP.
Without a CBF measurement, the AJDo2 does not give a quantitative measure of
metabolism but does provide a relative measure of the match between flow and
metabolism. This baseline value can then be used as an indicator of relative
change in this match, and therefore aid in the selection of appropriate therapy
for management of raised ICP. This makes the assumption that global CMRo2 is not
changing; this may or may not be true. Repeated CBF measurements are difficult
and thus there is increasing use of Doppler ultrasonography to determine flow
velocity.
The means available for attempting to modify the secondary injuries have
changed little over the past 15 years. Various therapies have come in and out of
fashion and the cascade in which the therapies are applied has changed. The
major therapies are:
-
hyperventilation;
-
patient position;
-
CSF drainage;
-
osmotic diuretics;
-
metabolic suppressants;
-
blood pressure increase;
-
hypothermia.
The new head injury guidelines for adults have generated certain
controversies, particularly as to how they should or can be applied to children,
and these will be discussed.
MECHANICAL VENTILATION
Most patients with a GCS of 8 or more will receive mechanical ventilation to
enable control of oxygenation and arterial carbon dioxide. The use of muscle
paralysis varies from unit to unit but is a necessary adjunct to controlled
respiration, in the authors' opinion, to prevent episodes of raised ICP that can
result from the patient fighting the ventilator, coughing with or without
suctioning; straining when episodes of decorticate or decerebrate posturing
occur or with movement of the patient. The major reason given for avoiding
muscle paralysis is that this results in loss of the clinical examination. If
the clinical examination is considered to be important, short-acting agents can
be used and reversed as often as the observer wishes. However, in the comatose
child it is difficult to see what information is obtained from the clinical
examination that cannot be obtained in some other way. If the ICP is not
monitored then the clinical examination may be the only way to identify a change
in the patient's neurological status, although such changes may be quite delayed
dependent on the status of pressure autoregulation and the patency of the
subarachnoid spaces. Very high ICP may be tolerated before a sudden drop in CBF
occurs or hemiation, and thus the clinical examination is not a very sensitive
measure of the events occurring in the intracranial space once coma is present.
The events that can be treated can all be identified early by adequate
monitoring of ICP, oxygen saturation, end tidal carbon dioxide, blood pressure,
SAP, and heart rate, and additional information can be gained from the use of
jugular bulb oxygen monitoring, CBF studies, or transcranial Doppler
ultrasonography. The treatable events are accumulation of an intracranial
hematoma, increased ICP not due to a surgical mass lesion, vasospasm, hyperemia,
seizures, and altered systemic parameters. Currently, deterioration of function
due to molecular events cannot be treated or indeed identified. Vasospasm can
produce increased ICP, decreased ICP, decreased CBF, increased velocity on
Doppler ultrasonography, or decreased jugular bulb oxygen. If evoked potential
monitoring is done, this may also show a change.
Clinically, once the patient is comatose the most likely identifiable change
is a deterioration in the motor findings, such as decorticate or decerebrate
posturing, change in pupil function (this would not be masked by muscle
paralysis), or changes in ventilation. Such changes become harder to identify
the lower on the GCS the patient is. Episodes of increased ICP are not
necessarily associated with alterations in the clinical findings or systemic
parameters, and if the ICP is not monitored and only the clinical examination is
used ICP pressure waves can be overlooked. It has been shown in animal models
that pressure autoregulation can be modified or abolished by simply raising and
lowering the ICP. Episodic increases in ICP can contribute to herniation. Thus,
in our opinion, the avoidance of multiple episodes of intracranial hypertension
is an important part of ICU care and this end is best attained by using muscle
paralysis in parallel with controlled ventilation. Obviously all ventilators
used must have automatic alarms to prevent inadvertent and unidentified
disconnection.
The ventilator settings must be appropriate to maximize venous return time
and avoid excess intrathoracic pressure or overdistension of the lungs that
could result in pneumothorax. In patients with pulmonary contusion or adult
respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), where high levels of positive and
expiratory pressure (PEEP) may be necessary, muscle paralysis has to be used.
HYPERVENTILATION
Other than raising the head of the bed, there is no faster way to lower the
ICP than by hyperventilation. The mechanism of action is presumed to be
arteriolar constriction, decreased CBF associated decreased cerebral blood
volume (CBV), and thus reduction in ICP by affecting the vascularcomponent.
Despite a decreased CBF, the brain can still extract adequate oxygen and
glucose; only when the CBF falls below 25-30% of normal is there any evidence of
substrate delivery compromise, and this is in the face of normal metabolism.
When the metabolic rate is lowered, lower CBF can be tolerated. Hyperventilation
can produce systemic alkalosis that results in a shift of the oxyhemoglobin
dissociation curve to the left, making release of oxygen at the tissue interface
less efficient. Therefore, an adequate hematocrit between 35 and 40 is advisable
to ensure adequate oxygen delivery to the neurons. A normal carbon dioxide
response is 3.5% alteration in CBF per mmHg change in Pa co2.,. A
recent study suggests that this response is preserved, though slightly blunted,
or increased after head injury in children, except in the most severe injuries
where death is impending. If, indeed, damaged tissue responds less to changes in
carbon dioxide than normal tissue, blood can in fact be shunted from normal
brain to the abnormal brain, but this has not been reported in head injury.
The theoretic risks or adverse effects of hyperventilation are (1) too great
a decrease in CBF resulting in ischemia and (2) the fact that the decreases in
CBF are transient, with the effect lasting only a short time. While the first
concern is a possibility, the most proximal control of CBF to the tissues is
local chemical autoregulation, the ability of brain tissue to regulate CBF
dependent on local tissue needs. The chemicals involved have not been clearly
defined but potential candidates are potassium, calcium, adenosine, and nitric
oxide. This control appears to be supreme since local changes in CBF occur all
the time in response to changes in metabolic activity without affecting global
CBF. Thus, if CBF is being lowered excessively by hyperventilation, local tissue
factors will be released and produce local vasodilatation and avoid ischemia.
Hypercarbia has been shown to result in an increase in CMRo2. The
reverse, a decrease in CMRo2, may occur with hyperventilation,
permitting an even greater decrease in CBF before ischemia.
While it has been shown in normal volunteers that continued hyperventilation
results in a gradual return of CBF to normal levels over 4-6 h, the evidence is
that after head injury the effects of hyperventilation are prolonged and the CBF
actually becomes lower with time over the first few days.76'77 This is probably
because CMR is decreased and therefore the flow required to match metabolism is
decreased such that local chemical autoregulation has no stimulus to release
vasodilating molecules. If there is an increased local requirement for blood
flow as a result of increased local metabolism, then that vascular bed should be
able to respond to the local tissue changes and increase CBF to supply the
demand in that area despite systemic hvpocarbia.
It is not clear in any individual child whether cerebral metabolism is
increased, decreased, or unchanged after severe head injury, and indeed the
response may vary with the type and severity of the injury. The reports
that are available show varied responses. If metabolism were raised and CBF
decreased, it is possible that hyperventilation could precipitate brain ischemia
if local chemical control was disturbed. In reports of oligemia after
hyperventilation, the ICP has been high, the CBF low, and the initial CBF very
low, but with associated low CMR0, and generally a low AJD02. Children who
develop very low flows appear to have devastating injuries. It is not at all
clear that hyperventilation can produce ischemia under any circumstance.
It seems likely that there are different responses in different areas of the
brain, as has been shown in animal models with both hypermetabolism and
hypometabolism.
The potential benefits of hyperventilation are several. The decreased CBF
will decrease CBV and therefore ICP. If there is hyperemia, the increased
cerebrovascular resistance will decrease end capillary pressure and vasogenic
edema formation. In addition, if there is hyperemia, the decreased flow may
avoid tissue hyperoxia and limit free radical formation. The alkalosis may have
a beneficial effect on tissue acidosis and reuptake of cytotoxic
neurotransmitters. Hyperventilation may help to re-establish pressure
autoregulation. The exact match between CBF and CMR in children with head
trauma is not well established but in most studies the AVDo2 is low or normal,
suggesting adequate or excess global flow for the amount of global metabolism.
From all of this lack of information, it is hard to be dogmatic. There is no
good evidence that moderate or even severe hyperventilation is detrimental, and
indeed most recent reports of outcome after head injuries in children have been
from units in which some degree of hyperventilation, often to levels of 20 mmHg,
are used when no other way to control ICP is working. In follow-up studies of MM
after severe head injury, there is no evidence of focal ischemic lesions
watershed infarcts) or global ischemia, and in these studies all the children
from one institution were hvperventilated as the initial therapy, and the degree
of hyperventilation was increased if ICP was hard to control. What is
established is that if children develop uncontrolled intracranial hypertension
they will die, and therefore it seems inappropriate to withhold a known valuable
therapy because of unsubstantiated potential side-effects. Hyperventilation to
around 30 mmHg is still an appropriate initial response in the comatose
head-injured child with increasing degrees of hyperventilation if the ICP is
high. In cases where increased hyperventilation is required, the child will be
receiving metabolic depressants as well, usually barbiturates or sedatives such
as Versed. One of the values of inserting the ICP monitor in the emergency room
is that the presence of intracranial hypertension can be diagnosed immediately.
If the ICP is 15 mmHg or less, a Paco2 between 30 and 35 mmHg is adequate. If
the ICP is above 15 mmHg, the hyperventilation can be set to achieve the highest
Paco2 that will lower ICP to 15-20 mmHg.
In adults the CBF appears to plateau at a Paco2 of 20 mmHg, with
further reduction in Paco2, having no effect on the CBF, presumably because of
local metabolic autoregulation. In children the plateau level of Paco7 has not
been established and we have seen decreases in CBF as Paco2 is lowered from 18
to 15 mmHg.78 As the ventilatory rate and volume are increased, adequate time
for central venous return is required to avoid venous congestion from raised
intrathoracic pressure and systemic hypotension as a result of decreased venous
return. The lowest level of Paco2 that is effective has not been defined, but if
the ICP remains above 30 mmHg after metabolic suppression and hypothermia the
Paco2 can be lowered as much as necessary if this is the only way to control the
ICP; we have used a Paco2 of 15 mmHg for 24 h or longer, with survival and
recovery. This is effective because of the reduced CMR requiring a much reduced
CBF for substrate delivery.
PATIENT POSITION
Concern has been raised about the value of the head-up position in patients
with increased ICP after head injury. The main theoretic concern has been that
the arterial pressure generated at the intracranial arterioles may be reduced by
a significant amount if the head is elevated and therefore the perfusion
pressure may be lowered, with a potential decrease in CBF. The arterial pressure
is usually zeroed at the level of the heart, while the ICP is zeroed at the
level of the external auditory meatus. If the patient is lying in the supine
position, flat in bed, then the CPP (mean arterial pressure (MAP) - ICP) has the
zero point at the same level for each variable. If the head is elevated, then
the calculated CPP can be inaccurate because of the discrepancy in the position
of the zero reference. With the head elevated, the distance above the heart of
the external meatus will vary depending on the size of the individual and the
degree of head elevation. In a 170-cm individual in the full upright position,
the distance from the heart to the external meatus is 30 cm; thus the measured
pressure in the head would be different by 22 mmHg if the zero point were taken
at the heart rather than at the meatus. In a 4-year-old child this difference
would be greater than 15 mmHg, assuming a height of 100 cm. In the head-up 300
position, the difference might be 5 mmHg. Thus the calculated CPP could be off
by that same amount, 5 mmHg. In a larger child or adult that value could reach 6
or 7 mmHg, one-third of the distance from the fully erect (90°) position.
Raising the head will also tend artificially to increase the arterial
measurement by a small amount. While of theoretic concern, papers actually
measuring CBF in patients before and after head elevation show that the decrease
in ICP produced by this maneuver offsets any decrease in SAP, resulting in a
stable or increased CBF, and that CBF was not affected.81'82 Thus there is no
reason not to use the head-up position as long as the patient has a :mal or
above normal SAP for age. This problem of transducer zero can be corrected by
zeroing both transducers to the same level, either the heart or the external
meatus.
CEREBRAL PERFUSION PRESSURE
In adult head-injured patients there is evidence from transcranial Doppler
studies that changes in velocity of flow measured by Doppler ultrasonography can
occur at a CPP below 70 mmHg, and therefore current recommendations are that CPP
be maintained above 70 mmHg on the assumption that these changes in velocity are
indicative of decreasing CBF. In children, the average CPP varies with age both
because the ICP and the arterial pressure change with age. The ICP is probably
less than 10 mmHg in a child with an open fontanelle, and rises to around 15
mmHg as the fontanelle closes. Likewise, normal MAP in a newborn is around 50
mmHg and rises to around 90 mmHg in the mid-teens. Thus the normal CPP in a
6-month-old may be 40-50 mmHg, and in a 14-year-old 70 mmHg. There is no ideal
CPP that is supported by experimental data in children and therefore therapy is
aimed at trying to maintain an ICP within 5-10 mmHg of normal, 15-25 mmHg and a
MAP that is equal to or higher than the normal mean for age. If there is
hypotension, immediate correction with blood, isotonic or hypertonic saline, and
or vasopressors is required. If the ICP cannot be lowered and the CPP is
dropping, then vasopressors may be carefully added to increase the MAP. This
should be done with an ICP monitor in place to be sure that the rise in MAP is
indeed accompanied by a rise in CPP. If the brain is tight or pressure
autoregulation defective, the ICP may rise with the MAP such that there is no
net gain and the rise in ICP may precipitate brain shift and herniation or
result in a global decrease in CBF. The proponents of CPP as the prime parameter
have failed to demonstrate that a CPP of 80 mmHg is always associated with the
same CBF. Older studies suggested that this was not so and that CBF was better
preserved when the CPP was maintained by a low ICP than by a high SAP.55~71'85
The use of jugular bulb monitoring of oxygen saturation and AJD02 can be helpful
in trying to estimate the match between CBF and CMRo2 before therapy and for
comparing the effects after therapy. If, after raising MAP, there is a decrease
in AJD02, this is supportive evidence that an increase in cerebral perfusion has
occurred, but assumes that no change in metabolism has taken place. There is no
sound foundation for selecting a particular CPP in children and it is still
advisable to treat ICP and MAP as separate variables that can be manipulated by
different mechanisms.
CONTROL OF RAISED ICP
There is still some disagreement as to whether there is clinical value to the
use of ICP monitoring in children following head injury. No studies have
positively shown that the use of this monitoring makes a difference to outcome.
To change outcome is not the proximal reason for using ICP monitoring, just as
measuring blood pressure is not believed to improve the outcome from shock. In
both these clinical settings, measurement of the actual pressure, ICP or SAP, is
necessary to define adequately the severity of the problem. The purpose of any
monitoring technique is to supply information about a system that is not easily
or sensitively gained in any other way and in which system there is reason to
believe that normal physiologic homeostasis is disturbed such that the normal
homeostatic mechanisms are dysfunctional. The information from the monitor is
then used to modify therapy and, in essence, to take over the homeostatic role
until recovery occurs. There is no purely clinical examination-based way to
measure the ICP. The presence of papilledema infers that intermittent increases
in ICP are occurring or have occurred, but says nothing about the actual ICP at
the time of the clinical examination and the absence of papilledema does not
correlate with the absence of raised ICP. Changes in clinical signs may be
caused by raised ICP (e.g. pupillary dilatation) but may equally be the result
of other alterations in function such as a seizure.
The ICP will be raised above normal in 75% of children with severe head
injury at some time during their course in the ICU. The problem is to identify,
in each patient, at which point the ICP is raised and therefore when therapy is
needed. Additional information that can be obtained only through monitoring is
whether the therapy given was effective in lowering the ICP by an appropriate
amount. This allows a logical decision to be made as to whether further therapy
is needed at that time and to identify when the ICP rises again to levels
requiring further therapy. While increased ICP is not the only problem
associated with severe head injury, it is associated with the majority of deaths
and is a parameter that can be treated. Therefore, ICP monitoring is a
recommended part of the current care of severely head-injured children. Any
child who is receiving therapy to affect the ICP can be more accurately and
appropriately treated when the ICP is being measured, and this is recommended in
children with a GCS of 8 or less. The current most frequently utilized
monitoring techniques are intraventricular via a ventriculostomv catheter or
intraparenchymal using either fiberoptic or solid-state technology. The former
has the advantage of allowing re-zeroing to be done, thus minimizing any
artifact from inherent drift within the measurement system and is the 'gold
standard' for measurement. The use of a ventricular catheter also allows
withdrawal of CSF as a therapeutic modality. The use of subdural or epidural
monitoring is sometimes done following surgery but the values are less certain
and the pitfalls greater. The reason for monitoring the ICP is to identify
increases that occur and to treat them, thus returning the ICP a more acceptable
or normal level. The ideal ICP is not known but if 15 mmHg is taken as normal,
the plan is to keep the ICP below 20 mmHg if possible. There are a number of
therapeutic options for lowering raised ICP.
CSF DRAINAGE
In approximately 50% of children with severe head injury the initial CT scan
shows evidence of brain swelling with small ventricles and subarachnoid spaces.
In these children the value of inserting a ventricular catheter to use both as
an ICP monitor and as a therapeutic modality to drain CSF has to be weighed
against the possible complications. These include inability to cannulate the
ventricle, the production of edema or hemorrhage as a result of multiple passes
of the catheter, and ventriculitis. The latter can be minimized by tunneling the
catheter subcutaneously as far as possible away from the drill-hole into the
cranium. In addition, if the ventricle is small there may be a dampened pressure
trace that may give unreliable values; if CSF is drained, this may dampen or
abolish the ICP pressure recording. Finally in this setting there is often
little or no CSF to drain, making this a not very helpful therapy because of
collapse of the ventricle around the catheter.
In children with normal or larger ventricles, or in whom one ventricle is
enlarged because of focal mass, then CSF drainage may be the only additional
therapy needed to control the ICP. In many children the ICP may be easily
controlled the first few days, then start to rise and be difficult to control at
a time when the child's neurologic status may be starting to improve. Repeat CT
at this time frequently shows resolution of the swelling with normal or
distended CSF spaces. With this CT scan the inferred pathology is increased
outflow resistance secondary to subarachnoid hemorrhage. At this stage after the
injury, ventricular or lumbar CSF drainage can produce rapid resolution of the
problem and is always worth trying rather than more intensive therapy.
OSMOTIC DIURETICS
The deliver of osmotic diuretics to the brain can be an effective way to
lower the ICP. It has been assumed that the mode of action is withdrawal of
extracellular water from the normal brain, resulting in a decreased brain volume
and lowered ICP. The exact action is not clear and may even be withdrawal of CSF
from the intracranial space. Rosner and Coley have suggested that the effects
are bound to the presence of intact pressure autoregulation. Early studies
showed effects from mannitol in the absence of autoregulanon and therefore this
mechanism may or may not be functional. The most frequently used agent is
mannitol given in doses of 0.25-1 g per kg intravenously. Mannitol is excreted
by the kidneys and is not metabolized in the body to any significant degree, and
thus tends to remove free water from the body in the urine. Thus dehydration can
easily occur, resulting in alteration in viscosity of the blood and hypotension
if adequate fluid replacement is not maintained. The mannitol must be delivered
over 10-15 mm to prevent alteration of SAP. In children who are sedated and
paralyzed, the rapid infusion of mannitol will raise the blood pressure and can
result in an early increase in ICP before the ICP is reduced. This is probably
due to an increase in intravascular volume related to the too-rapid infusion.
The MAP rises, which can increase ICP by increasing CBF as a result of increased
CP?, increasing brain turgor as a result of the increased MAP, and producing
direct cerebral vasodilatation as a result of the osmotic load. Mannitol can
also produce a decrease in MAP by having a direct vasodilating effect on the
arterioles as a result of the increased osmotic load. This shrinks the vascular
pacemaker cells and can result in fewer muscle cell contacts, with resultant
vasodilatation. In general the use of mannitol should be discontinued if the
serum osmolality exceeds 330 mosmol 1~ because of the risk of deposition of
mannitol crystal in the renal tubules and resultant tubular necrosis. The use of
mannitol is often reserved for the later, post 48 h, treatment of head trauma
since there is little evidence of brain edema in the early stages and edema is
the pathology for which mannitol seems most indicated. Mannitol is usually given
by repeated bolus injection to boost the serum osmolality intermittently.
However, it can be given as a bolus followed by a continuous infusion to try to
maintain a specific serum osmolality. There is little rationale for a
fixed-bolus schedule for mannitol, since the effect of a given dose may vary
markedly both in the ICP decrease achieved and in the length of time over which
the pressure stays down. The frequency of administration and the dosage need to
be individualized for each child.
Urea is another osmotic diuretic that is still used occasionally. The final
agent is glycerol. This can be given via a nasogastric tube or specially
prepared for intravenous use with a special filter. Glycerol is metabolized by
the liver and probably the brain, and therefore has a less dehydrating effect as
its renal excretion is low. It does not produce tubular necrosis and before the
serum osmolality can be increased to higher levels. The biggest complication
with glycerol is that, as a result of liver metabolism, the serum free fatty
acid levels can get verv high and produce pulmonary capillary obstruction. Thus
serum free fatty acid levels need to be monitored carefully. The usual dosage
schedule is 0.5 g kg-' as a bolus and then 0.5 g kg-' as an infusion over 30-60
mm. Like mannitol, it is repeated as needed, dependent on the ICP.
HYPOTHERMIA
Children have a higher relative surface area to weight ratio than adults and,
when paralyzed and sedated for controlled ventilation, tend to lose heat easily
such that the core temperature in the ICU is often below normal. It is not
necessary to reverse that as there may be value in the lowered core temperature.
For each 1°C change in temperature there is an approximately 10% change in
cerebral metabolism. Thus it is desirable to prevent hyperthermia since this
will result in increased substrate demand in the brain, requiring increased CBF.
The ability of the CBF to increase may be dampened or prevented by increased
ICP, decreased CPP, and maximum existing vasodilatation such that a further
increase in CBF is not possible and cerebral ischemia results in further injury.
Alternatively, if vasodilatation does occur as a result of the increased
temperature, this will increase the cerebral blood volume and may result in a
hard-to-control increase in ICP.
Deliberate efforts to lower the core temperature to 32-33°C can be helpful in
controlling otherwise impossible-to-control ICP. The decreased temperature
lowers metabolism, lowers CBF and cerebral blood volume, and therefore ICP.
There also may be some protective effect when waves of increased ICP occur since
the lowered metabolic rate will permit the brain to tolerate greater and longer
episodes of lowered CBF. If moderate hypothermia is to be used, the patient
needs to be hydrated adequately, and it is better to use this modality early in
the course of therapy if it is clear that high and difficult-to-control ICP is a
problem. Hypothermia may reduce the requirements for other therapies.
The potential danger of this level of hypothermia is interference with
phagocyte activity and pulmonary ciliarv function, with resultant pneumonia.
This has been reported in Reye's syndrome but has not been a problem in the
treatment of children with head injurv. However, in children with severe
pulmonary contusion it may be safer to avoid hypothermia of this degree as they
have an increased risk of pneumonia.
METABOLIC DEPRESSANTS
Most children who are being treated for severe head injury by controlled
ventilation are on some medication to minimize pain, usually fentanvl, and often
a soporific such as Versed to allay any anxiety since we have no way to measure
this in the comatose child. The use of muscle relaxants varies dependent on the
treating physician. There is no question that, despite sedation, the children
can fight the ventilator, resulting in increases in ICP, and muscle relaxants
are generally used in addition to other medications. Neither fentanyl nor Versed
has been shown to have any ICP-lowering effect and, if a sedative is required,
it may be more appropriate to use a barbiturate or other soporific with known
ability to lower raised ICP. In children in whom the ICP is high and difficult
to maintain below 20 mmHg despite multiple medications, the use of pentobarbital
at an early stage as the metabolic suppressant, anti-anxiety drug plus
anti-seizure drug seems to make more sense than to use a multiplicity of drugs.
The side-effects of increased vascular resistance and hypertension usually occur
when such drugs are used after mannitol and in a dehydrated child and therefore,
when the concerns for prolonged raised ICP are present or when early therapy
such as position and hyperventilation is ineffective in lowering the ICP,
barbiturates have a role. They have been shown to be capable of lowering the ICP
in this setting.
ANTIEPILEPTICS
Seizures have been reported in 30% of severely head-injured children. Many of
these are single seizures and often occur around the time of the impact.
Seizures occurring in the first hour are often isolated events and do not
require medication. Therapy with antiepileptic drugs, usually phenytoin or now
phosphenvtoin, is necessary only for repeated or prolonged seizures. The
beneficial value of prophylactic antiepileptic medication has not been
demonstrated in pediatric head injury. There are many pediatric head injury
units that do use prophylactic anticonvulsants, and at the present time this
remains the choice of the treating physicians.
OUTCOME
The factors that are useful in predicting final outcome after severe head
injury have been enumerated in a number of studies. Very young children seem to
do worse than toddlers and older children, and it is likely that this is related
more to the cause and therefore the pathophysiologv of the injury than to the
age of the child. Some 10-30% of infant trauma under 2 years of age, at least in
the USA, may be due to non-accidental or inflicted trauma. Suffice it to say
that the frequency of delayed medical attention, hypoxia, and ischemia are very
high and seem to be the major reason for the poor outcome.
Predictors of poor outcome for accidental injury include multiple trauma and
early hypoxia or shock. Other factors include the GCS, especially the motor
score which is the easiest part of the GCS to apply to children of all ages,
pupillary function, and high Injury Severity Score, CT pattern, and ICP.
Mortality rates in children remain high: 40-60% for children with a GCS score,
of 3 or 4. The mortality rate for children with GCS of 3 remains around 70%,
whereas for a GCS of 4 the rate drops to 10-20%, and that in children with a GCS
of 5 or above is less than 10%, and zero in some reports.
Morbidity following pediatric trauma varies depending on the measures used to
evaluate recovery: the more sensitive the measure the greater percentage of
children with an identified deficit. If the Glasgow outcome scale is used to
evaluate survivors, the numbers look very good with only a small percentage of
children in the vegetative state, approximately 25% severely disabled, and 75%
making a good recovery or being moderately disabled. Such a limited measure does
not reflect the true situation. Following a severe injury, even if no head
injury occurred, 50% of children will exhibit functional limitations at 6
months. In addition there are emotional and social effects on the family as a
whole, with up to 40% of families experiencing a change in the family unit
within the first year and almost 50% of siblings who were not injured
demonstrating social, emotional, or educational difficulties. Thus, even in the
absence of specific brain injury, the adjustment of the injured child and the
family is prolonged and difficult. Counseling and support are required and
should be an automatic part of any trauma system, otherwise the enormous
expenditure of money and effort to treat the trauma in the acute stages is
undermined and the goal of returning the child to a normal integrated social and
educational system is not met.
Specific problems related to cerebral injury also occur but seem to be
predominant in children with severe trauma. Recent findings of frequent damage
to the frontal and temporal lobes may account for the neurocognitive and some of
the behavioral sequelae. Following severe traumatic brain injury, frontal lobe
tasks such as the Tower of London test are affected, even in children with
normal MRI scans. These children do have physiologic problems such as decreased
CBF in the frontal lobes. Volumetric studies have shown that the tissue loss
appears to be predominantly gray matter of the frontal lobe. Thus the common
complaint from the family that the child is not the same as before is probably
true. With increased information about frontal circuits that may play a role in
stress, depression, and possibly other higher functions, subtle changes in
performance and behavior may well have a neurochemicoanatomic basis.
The effects of head injury on psychiatric disturbance has been another area
of question. An increased occurrence of new psychiatric problems occurs even
after moderate or minor injuries, with more reliable increases after severe
injury. Whether these too will turn out to be the result of interference in the
frontal-thalamic-brainstem circuits remains to be seen. Similarly, problems with
memory, concentration, behavior, and impulse control all occur. The problem of
neurotoxin transmitter release and other biochemical alterations may be the
pathology that underlies these subtle problems, which are not easily correlated
with MM abnormalities. If this is the case then the role of chemical mediators
may not be measurable by looking at mortality data but only by measures of
cognitive recovery.
It is clear that severe head injury almost always results in some measurable
alteration in cerebral function: neurologic, cognitive, psychiatric, or social.
Whether the pathology that is responsible for severe disability, the vegetative
state, and death is the same as that responsible for the more subtle changes is
not clear, but current evidence suggests that there are differences. The major
two are the lack of evidence of secondary ischemic injury and the relatively low
incidence of diffuse axonal injury that is reported in follow-up MM scans. The
pathophysiology of death from head injury may be different from that associated
with recovery, not because there is simply less intensity of injury but because
different pathologic, processes are occurring. If this is true, it suggests that
best therapy should not be based on information obtained from the study of
mortality but from studies of recovery.
CONCLUSION
Severe accidental head injury in children carries a low mortality rate of
approximately 20%. The outcome is dependent on:
-
severity of injury as measured by the GCS;
-
associated shock;
-
hypoxia in the emergency room;
-
initial CT scan;
-
pupil reflexes.
These factors, in combination, have the best predictive value for mortality.
Recovery, if it occurs, can be equally good with any GCS. The pathology is
variable over the time course of the injury and includes primary and secondary
factors that can influence the outcome. Early pathology is hypoxia, ischemia,
shock, and intracranial operative mass lesions. Later, brain swelling and raised
ICP occur. This is then followed by brain edema, secondary ischemic swelling,
increased outflow resistance to CSF, traumatic aneurysms and, later,
hydrocephalus and epilepsy. The best therapy then changes over time and a clear
understanding of the changing pathophysiology is important. The cause of death
appears to be severe brain injury with raised ICP and usually occurs in the
first 48 h. The pathology in children who die or are in a vegetative state is
DAI, brain swelling, and secondary ischemic injury. In children who survive it
seems that the pathology is less commonly DAI, there is little evidence of
ischemia, and focal contusions of the frontal and temporal are the most frequent
findings. In addition, loss of cortical gray matter volume in the frontal lobes
is common.
In children who do not die, a high incidence of subtle or blatant changes in
cognition, social function, and behavior is seen, and long-term support is
required to maximize the recovery process. Efforts to prevent injury and support
systems to maximize social recovery are essential components of any trauma
system. |